Dolly Wink Pencil eyeliner in black review! (sponsored by Artie)

Hello everyone!!! Hope you are all doing well ^__^!
Today I'm going to review the Dolly Wink Pencil eyeliner in black that Artiestyle.net kindly sponsored!
This is the package *____* soooo cute!
It has a big bow and Tsubasa's face xP! I couldn't throw it away, so I put it as decoration in my room XD! haha!

This is how the eyeliner looks like when you first get it! soo cute ;___;!

1-You can make thin or thick lines!

2-It doesn't smudge at all, not even with water o__o! I don't  know if it's supposed to be waterproof, but I think it is, it took me forever to get it off my hand with water! and even though I was rubbing it really hard, it didn't smudge *0*!

Here how it looks on my eye, it is more like a charcoal color :/, not as black as I expected.

Packaging ★★★★★ -Cutest packaging everr! so pink and pretty *___*!
Color ★★☆☆☆- It is too light :/ I guess is good if you are aiming for a soft look
Texture ★★★★★- Love it, very soft! it applies smoothly and evenly
Plus I love that it does not smudges and is waterproof!

Overall- ★★★☆☆

I you liked it you can get it HERE

And if you spend $20 or more at  Artie you can get 10% off by using the
CODE: Yummy

That's it for today!!
Bye bye!!